NFLDraftScout.com ratings: 1. Harrison, 2. Maye, 3. Williams

Nov 25, 2023; Raleigh, North Carolina, USA; North Carolina Tar Heels quarterback Drake Maye (10) throws a pass against the North Carolina State Wolfpack during the first half at Carter-Finley Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rob Kinnan-USA TODAY Sports
Nov 25, 2023; Raleigh, North Carolina, USA; North Carolina Tar Heels quarterback Drake Maye (10) throws a pass against the North Carolina State Wolfpack during the first half at Carter-Finley Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rob Kinnan-USA TODAY Sports

With the College Football Playoffs and some 42 Bowl games all in line, let's take a look at updated player ratings for the 2024 Draft by NFLDraftScout.com.

There is no movement at the very top, where NDS moved Ohio State wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. to No. 1 in early November, followed by Norrth Carolina quarterback Drake May at No. 2, leapfrogging USC quarterback Caleb Williams, who was numero uno through October. 

Our ratings aren't meant to predict where the player will be picked, which is impacted by team needs, but rather how well we believe they will perform as pro football players, with a bit of a boost to quarfterbacks based on their importance to the game. 

In his last two seasons, Harrison has been the most consistently outstanding player in college football and looks like he has the tools to join his father, Marvin Harrison Sr.,  in the Pro Football Hall of Fame if he performs at this level for a decade or so in the NFL. 

But nothing is for sure. Yesterday (Dec. 7, 2023) Harrison said he is pondering a return to Ohio State to pursue a Big 10 Championship and a win over Michigan. We'll see. 

There are a few situations such as that, including standout quarterbacks Quinn Ewers, a redshirt sophomore at Texas, and Shedeu Sanders a junior at Colorado whose father and head coach, Deion Sanders, says will not enter the NFL draft.

We rated Ewers No. 39 overall we agree with those who believe he could use another year in college. Although he has arm talent and a cool demeanor reminiscent of Justin Herbert (Oregon/Chargers), Ewers won't even be 21 until March. We don't include Sanders in the ratings because Deion sounds firm, but if Shedeu were in the 2024 draft he would be a first day pick. 

LSU quarterback Jayden Daniels was the most upwardly mobile quarterback this season and he moved  to No. 5 this month. We didn't like what appeared to be a run-first approach last yar, but he seemed to find a good balance with his ample abilities.

Rounding out our first round prospects are Oregon's prolific Bo Nix at No. 14 and Washington's left-handed gun slinger, Michael Penix, at NO. 15, although we remain concerned about his long history of critical leg injuries. We rate  Michigan quarterback J. J. McCarthy at No. 41 overall although it is unclear if he will enter the draft. His production this year moved him higher on many lists, but we aren't sure how well he would perform with a taam that didn't have the best semi-amateur football roster on the planet. 

 Here is a look at all quarterbacks we believe have draft potential in 2024

 

Rnk Player School Pos. Pos. Rnk Ht Wt Class 40 Proj. Rnd
2
Drake Maye North Carolina QB 1 6043 230 rSo 4.62 1
3
Caleb Williams Southern California QB 2 6005 215 Jr 4.48 1
5
Jayden Daniels LSU QB 3 6032 210 rSr 4.52 1
14
Bo Nix Oregon QB 4 6016 217 rSr 4.62 1
15
Michael Penix Jr. Washington QB 5 6025 213 rSr 4.64 1
39
Quinn Ewers Texas QB 6 6021 195 rSo 4.76 1-2
41
J.J. McCarthy Michigan QB 7 6031 202 Jr 4.52 1-2
75
Michael Pratt Tulane QB 8 6025 220 Sr 4.7 2-3
154
Joe Milton III Tennessee QB 9 6051 235 rSr 4.65 4-5
163
Sam Hartman Notre Dame QB 10 6005 212 rSr 4.76 5
180
KJ Jefferson Arkansas QB 11 6025 247 rSr 4.76 5-6
202
Austin Reed Western Kentucky QB 12 6012 220 rSr 4.73 6
208
Spencer Rattler South Carolina QB 13 6002 217 rSr 4.74 6
233
Taulia Tagovailoa Maryland QB 14 5105 208 rSr 4.73 6-7
255
Jordan Travis Florida State QB 15 6005 212 rSr 4.54 7
272
Devin Leary Kentucky QB 16 6012 217 rSr 4.78 7-HPFA
278
Garrett Shrader Syracuse QB 17 6043 225 rSr 4.6 7-HPFA
294
Phil Jurkovec Pittsburgh QB 18 6052 235 rSr 4.72 7-HPFA
308
Brennan Armstrong North Carolina State QB 19 6010 212 rSr 4.67 7-HPFA
316
Spencer Sanders Mississippi QB 20 6005 210 rSr 4.5 7-HPFA

 

Latest Player Notes

How Wisconsin athletes are benefiting from a unique NIL deal with Madison's Exact Sciences

Feb 17, 2024MJ Hammill entered what can be a scary time of an athlete’s life in mid-December.She went into the volleyball ...

Mike Griffith: Texas is Georgia's primary focus this offseason

February 16, 2024The Georgia Bulldogs face three SEC contenders on the road next season in Alabama, Texas and Ole Miss. According ...

Navigating a season that could see Texas play Georgia more than once

February 17, 2024The Texas Longhorns and Georgia Bulldogs will play in Austin on Oct. 19. It may not be the only time they ...

After some key departures from the team, Dykes got busy in the portal this offseason.

5:11 PM on Feb 16, 2024Biggest unanswered question: Who will emerge as the clear WR1?Before last season, Williams was the ...

How Louisville football coach Jeff Brohm balances transfer portal, high school recruiting

Louisville Courier JournalCollege football used to buzz on the first Wednesday in February, but Louisville football's office ...

Bob Asmussen | Illinois defense counting on linebackers to plug the gaps

College Football Reporter/ColumnistCHAMPAIGN — A new linebacker coach is in place at Illinois, and Archie McDaniel said he ...

Where Alabama’s quarterback group stands before spring practice

Alabama football’s offense is going to look different this season. Kalen DeBoer has replaced the retired Nick Saban as head ...

Why did AJ McCarron return to the St. Louis Battlehawks?

When AJ McCarron joined the resurrected XFL last year, the former Alabama All-American hadn’t played since suffering a knee ...

Colorado football self-reported 11 minor NCAA violations from Deion Sanders’ first year with Buffs

1/26/2024The Colorado football program has self-reported 11 minor NCAA violations since the hiring of head coach Deion Sanders ...

What Steve Young said about today’s NFL quarterbacks

By Jackson Payne Steve Young may have enjoyed a Hall of Fame career in the NFL, but that doesn’t stop him from feeling just ...
See More Player Notes